BADM 318-01 2007 Project Plan Presentation Peer Feedback

After each presentation, please complete this peer feedback form. Don't complete during the presentations! If you want, you can take some brief notes on paper to remind you of any comments you want to make. Please take this process seriously and be constructive with your comments. Average scores will be used as part of the presentation mark. DON'T ASSESS YOUR OWN GROUP! Your participation in this feedback process is part of your participation mark.



A red asterisk (*) indicates required questions.


  1. What is your first name?*


  1. What is your last name?*


  1. Which group are you evaluating?  *


  1. Please score on scale of 1-10 how you think the team performed on the following criteria:

    Professional and Support Material Includes professional look of the team and their approach, did they meet the time restriction. Quality and effectiveness of any support material. i.e. PowerPoint presentation, layout, visual charts, graphs, etc

      *


  1. Please score on scale of 1-10 how you think the team performed on the following criteria:

    Presentation Ability How well did the team present. Energy, presence, confidence, tone, volume, stance, eye contact, knew the material, were well prepared, didn’t read notes too much, etc.

      *


  1. Please score on scale of 1-10 how you think the team performed on the following criteria:

    Thoroughness and believability of the project plan: Has the project been well though out, do you have confidence that the team will meet the project goals within the constraints? Is the budget realistic, is the time scheduled doable?

      *


  1. Please score on scale of 1-10 how you think the team performed on the following criteria:

    Organization and team work: Did the order of the material make sense, were transitions between members smooth

      *


  1. Please score on scale of 1-10 how you think the team performed on the following criteria:

    General Content: Did the team do an executive summary, identify appropriate & measurable goals and objectives, and did they define the project priorities, constraints, team and deliverables? How well was the project scope defined? Did they choose an appropriate structure? Were risks and contingency plans developed?

      *


  1. What do you think this group did well? Please keep your comments brief.*


  1. What do you think could have been improved? Please keep your comments brief.*