| A | B |
|---|
| Kevin & Drew | Season 1, All-Stars/Fraternity Brothers; Lifelong Friends |
| Joe & Bill | Season 1, All-Stars/Life Partners |
| Frank & Margarita | Season 1/Separated Parents |
| Rob & Brennan | Season 1/Lawyers-Best Friends |
| Oswald & Danny | Season 2, All-Stars/Best Friends |
| Tara & Wil | Season 2/Separated Couple |
| Chris & Alex | Season 2/Lifelong Friends |
| John Vito & Jill | Season 3, All-Stars/Dating; Formerly Dating |
| Derek & Drew | Season 3/Twins-Models |
| Ken & Gerard | Season 3/Brothers |
| Teri & Ian | Season 3, All-Stars/Married Parents |
| Flo & Zach | Season 3/Friends |
| Jon & Al | Season 4/Best Friend-Clowns |
| David & Jeff | Season 4/Best Friends |
| Kelly & Jon | Season 4/Engaged |
| Reichen & Chip | Season 4/Married |
| Charla & Mirna | Season 5, All-Stars/Cousins |
| Linda & Karen | Season 5/Bowling Moms |
| Colin & Christie | Season 5/Dating |
| Chip & Kim | Season 5/Married Parents |
| Jonathan & Victoria | Season 6/Married Entrepreneurs |
| Adam & Rebecca | Season 6/Formerly Dating |
| Kris & Jon | Season 6/Dating Long Distance |
| Freddy & Kendra | Season 6/Engaged Models |
| Meredith & Gretchen | Season 7/Married-Retired |
| Rob & Amber | Season 7, All-Stars/Engaged; Newlyweds |
| Uchenna & Joyce | Season 7, All-Stars/Married |
| Gaghan Family | Family Edition/Dad, Mom, & Kids |
| Weaver Family | Family Edition/Widow & Kids |
| Bransen Family | Family Edition/Dad & Daughters |
| Linz Family | Family Edition/Siblings |
| Ray & Yolanda | Season 9/Dating |
| Eric & Jeremy | Season 9/Friends |
| BJ & Tyler | Season 9/Best Friends |
| David & Mary | Season 10, All-Stars/Coalminer & Wife |
| Erwin & Godwin | Season 10/Brothers |
| Dustin & Kandice | Season 10, All-Stars/Beauty Queens |
| Lyn & Karlyn | Season 10/Single Moms - Friends |
| Rob & Kimberly | Season 10/Dating |
| Tyler & James | Season 10/Models |
| Eric & Danielle | All-Stars/Dating |
| Azaria & Hendekea | Season 12/Brother-Sister |
| Kynt & Vyxsin | Season 12/Dating Goths |
| Nathan & Jennifer | Season 12/Dating |
| Nicolas & Donald | Season 12/Grandson-Grandfather |
| Ronald & Christina | Season 12/Father-Daughter |
| TK & Rachel | Season 12/Newly Dating |
| Toni & Dallas | Season 13/Mother-Son |
| Andrew & Dan | Season 13/Frat Boys |
| Ken & Tina | Season 13/Separated |
| Nick & Starr | Season 13/Brother-Sister |
| Margie & Luke | Season 14/Mother-Son |
| Jaime & Cara | Season 14/Former NFL Cheerleaders |
| Tammy & Victor | Season 14/Sibling-Lawyers |
| Flight Time & Big Easy | Season 15/Harlem Globetrotters |
| Brian & Ericka | Season 15/Married |
| Sam & Dan | Season 15/Brothers |
| Meghan & Cheyne | Season 15/Dating |
